ice age mtg cards Guys Finish First Covered Island from Ice Age is a Common nonfoil single Magic Magic The Gathering MTG Ice

Further recommendations are highly dependent on what type of deck and colors you are playing, as well as the format

Even though the card totals are much higher than the asking price, there arent enough individually valuable cards for these decks to be worth it as an investment for collectors

Goblin Bushwhacker gives you exactly that

And when you deploy T2 Wrenn and Six versus a T1 Esper Sentinel/Ragavan, Nimble Pilferer youve almost won

That enchantment was originally part of 1998's Stronghold set and can only be found in The List (a curated list of older cards that no longer appear in Play Boosters nowadays), making it rather hard to acquire unless you pay the circa $4 to buy it on some kind of marketplace